New York I love you, but you’re getting me down
1/10/2008I’m back from my first time in The City in roundabout 18 months. It was a wonderful, if exhausting experience: working by day and catching up with people by night, for a whole week, certainly takes its toll.
I have a sense that New York will always feel like home to me, even if it were emptied of all those close to me who are there. It is at root physiological, an emotional bond alloyed by sight and scent.
Though I have seen New York as long as I have smelled it, it is the latter sense – oldest in nature that it is – which is the strongest and most changeless. When I first came to The City, I saw it with the same drawling yokel eyes that most kids, emerging from the tunnel that goes from Wichita to Williamsburg, do – though I was young enough to be dazzeled without any sense of irony. Though I am still as in love with the face of New York, with its craggy, stolid beauty, as I was when I arrived, the initial romance has long sense dulled. There remain places and moments of architectural fancy that bring me back to that honeymoon – crossing the East River on the subway, craning my neck about the deco giants of lower Manhattan, or wandering idly among brownstones – but it is not too often that the look alone burnishes my heart.
The impact of smell, however, never abates, no matter how long it lingers in the back of the sinus, or how accustomed I come to it. There is a crisp smell of autumn in New York that I particularly love – it has the cleanest, most provincial quality that metropolitan air ever acquires. I was happy enough to take long draughts of this on my visit. But there is another smell, far less pleasant but far more distinguished, that strikes my olfactory bulb like a wielded signpost. Most people would call it “trash”, but that does it little justice, nor fully describes its range. I have to go in for “miasma” or “funk”, because it is not the smell of trash alone, but the smell of trash in the sun, of foul air banked in sewers and subway tunnels, of the animal and vegetable debris of Chinatown markets. It is neither as simple nor as small as a single wastebin. It is almost regal in its awfulness.
I imagine every major city will have it’s own variation of this miasma, depending upon their own infrastructures, cuisines, hygiene, and culture generally. One could say that city funk has it’s own terroir, and I believe that this is why – when rounding a corner into a new, passing through storm drain halitus, or waiting on the subway platform – wherever I was struck by New York’s particular scent, I was inspired by a sense of home and the familiar.
Places are nothing without people, of course, and it would be difficult to say that empty phonebook and solitary evenings could be replaced by the smell of waste. I am not saying that, simply stating the obvious – that smell orients. Friends are, of course, the meat of the matter, and this trip to New York, more than anything, reminded me how wonderful it is to have one’s people. To make a few calls and end up with a crowded table at brunch, or for a midweek dinner, is beyond heartening. It is one of the more reaffirming sensations that must exist outside of faith, conjugal, or filial love. To see my people, changed only in age, and with age now a topic of conversation, was the highlight of my trip. I only regret not being able to see more. The obvious corollary to the equation between absence and fondness is this: reunions are the sweetest of events, even if they are short.


